Appearance
Source:
docs/adr/0005-per-cluster-affiliate-disclosure.md. Edit it there; this page is generated at build time.
Disclosure repeated per buy cluster, not once per page or in the footer
We considered a single site-wide disclosure in the footer (what the site did before), one banner at the top of each monetised page, or a compact disclosure repeated beside every cluster of buy buttons. We chose the last, and it is deliberately redundant. 16 CFR Part 465 is a trade regulation rule with civil penalties (currently $53,088 per violation), and §465.1(c)(4) states that a disclosure "must be unavoidable" and "is not clear and conspicuous if a consumer must take any action, such as clicking on a hyperlink or hovering over an icon, to see it." The FTC's Endorsement Guides FAQ then rules out both cheaper options in terms: a footer disclosure fails because "many won't read to the very end", and a single homepage disclosure fails because visitors "might read individual reviews… without seeing the disclosure on your home page."
The operative design constraint is the FTC's co-visibility test: disclosure is adequate when "the reader can see both the review containing that disclosure and the link at the same time", and inadequate when the two "are separated." On a long "best of" listicle with a buy button per entry, one top-of-page banner therefore does not cover the buttons further down — hence the entry variant of <x-affiliate-disclosure> rendered per entry. The wording is also constrained rather than chosen: "Paid link" is expressly blessed by the FTC, whereas "affiliate link" is expressly inadequate ("consumers might not understand that 'affiliate link' means that the person placing the link is getting paid"), as is a bare "Buy now" button. Merchant-required strings (Amazon's "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.") live on the Merchant record so they travel with the link.
A related rule is enforced by convention rather than code, and must stay that way: revenue must never be an input to ranking. §255.4(b)(3) holds that paid rankings are deceptive "regardless of whether the website makes express claims of objectivity", that disclosing the payments "would be inadequate", and that even a methodology which merely correlates rank with merchant relationships is "also misleading". So ordering comes from rank/sort/score only — never from commission rate, EPC, or click revenue. The footer disclosure was kept as a backstop, but it is no longer load-bearing.